The American Heart Association begs to differ with Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. on some of the finer points of his dietary guidelines. Of course, they’re totally onboard with the imperative to “eat real food.” After all, who’s in favor of fake food? But AHA has issued new guidance with a subtle rebuke to RFK Jr.’s messaging on plants, meat, and saturated fat.
Where RFK Jr. is shouting “beef is back,” AHA says get more of your protein from plants. Rather than pushing whole milk, AHA is “still recommending low-fat and fat-free dairy products.” And AHA is drawing a bright red line under the recommendation to limit saturated fats to ten percent or less of the calories we consume.
That last point on saturated fats is a little muddled in the messaging from RFK Jr. Posing with a big steak sporting birthday candles does not help.
A Nine-Point Plan
The AHA guidance, published last week in Circulation, is clear and concise. It offers nine points of to define healthy dietary patterns.
- Balance how much you eat with how active you are.
- Eat a variety and plenty of vegetables and fruit.
- Choose whole grains.
- Seek healthy protein sources: more from plants and less from red meat.
- Favor foods with unsaturated fat over saturated fat, stick with low-fat and fat-free dairy.
- Go with minimally processed, not ultra-processed foods.
- Avoid added sugars.
- Stay clear of foods with too much salt.
- No level of alcohol consumption is safe.
What Controversy?
Both organizations seem to be taking pains to emphasize points of agreement rather than their obvious differences. AHA has said it “welcomes” the HHS guidelines and “commends the inclusion of several important science-based recommendations.” An HHS spokesman told the Wall Street Journal the agency and AHA are “aligned on the major issues: eat real food, avoid highly processed food, and limit refined grains and added sugar.”
Both organizations say they want to “work collaboratively” on shared agendas.
But RFK Jr. has a hearty appetite for controversy.
Click here for the AHA guidance, here, here, and here for further perspective.
Kennedy, Candles, and Steak, photograph by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services / X
Subscribe by email to follow the accumulating evidence and observations that shape our view of health, obesity, and policy.
April 07, 2026 at 4:20 pm, David Brown said:
The American Heart Association is right to advise consumers to eat less meat but wrong to advise restricting beef intake on the basis of its saturated fat content. RFK is right to advise people to avoid seed oils and consume tallow and butter. However, he does not realize that grain-fed animal products, particularly poultry and pork, are problematic for human health due to the arachidonic acid and linoleic acid content. Norwegian animal science researchers suggested this solution: “It is shown how an unnaturally high omega-6/omega-3 fatty acid concentration ratio in meat, offal and eggs (because the omega-6/omega-3 ratio of the animal diet is unnaturally high) directly leads to exacerbation of pain conditions, cardiovascular disease and probably most cancers. It should be technologically easy and fairly inexpensive to produce poultry and pork meat with much more long-chain omega-3 fatty acids and less arachidonic acid than now, at the same time as they could also have a similar selenium concentration as is common in marine fish. The health economic benefits of such products for society as a whole must be expected vastly to outweigh the direct costs for the farming sector. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3031257/