Posts Tagged ‘scientific debate’

Is Excess Soybean Oil in the Food Supply a Factor in Obesity?

December 1, 2025 — Soybean oil is the most common cooking oil in the American food supply. By far. If you are consuming a lot of ultra-processed foods, you are consuming a lot of soybean oil. Now, the University of California at Riverside says that a new study links soybean oil to obesity. Specifically, scientists at the university have […]

The Growing Roar of Condemnation for Ultra-Processed Foods

November 20, 2025 — “Big food is taking over,” says Barry Popkin, adding an exclamation point in the New York Times to a growing roar of condemnation for ultra-processed foods. The occasion for this is the publication of three new papers – plus an editorial – all at once in The Lancet this week. Popkin was an author on […]

“Only 12% of American Adults Are Metabolically Healthy”

July 31, 2025 — It was fascinating yesterday hearing former FDA Commissioner David Kessler close out a symposium on food noise, chatting about his views on healthy weight. He marvelled at the size of the problem and how, after years of studying it, people have difficulty with agreeing on a definition for “clinical obesity.” How hard can it be? […]

Crunching Numbers on the Definition of Clinical Obesity

July 20, 2025 — Six months have passed since the Lancet Commission on the definition of clinical obesity aimed to “settle the ongoing dispute around the idea of obesity as a disease.” At the time, we had doubts about this new definition “settling” disputes about defining obesity. Indeed, we have seen lots of vigorous discussion, but not a lot […]

Has the Obsolescence of BMI for Screening Been Overstated?

April 21, 2025 — It is really easy to beat up on the lowly BMI. The Lancet Commission on clinical obesity gently kicked it to the curb by saying BMI “can both overestimate and underestimate adiposity” and thus declared its obsolescence as a singular measure for excess adiposity. “Excess adiposity should be confirmed by either direct measurement of body […]

Mixing Food Noise, Addiction, and Ultra-Processed Foods

March 8, 2025 — “It takes years for scientists to prove things we’ve always known were true – like food addiction.” This thought emerged from the meeting this week of the Roundtable on Obesity Solutions. The current science of food noise was a focus. In the course of some outstanding presentations, three distinct and distinctly challenging concepts mixed together […]

What Is Hard About a Clinical Diagnosis of Obesity?

January 28, 2025 — It is fascinating to watch the public discourse about newly proposed criteria from the Lancet Commission for a clinical diagnosis of obesity unfold. The headline is easy. “It’s time to move beyond BMI alone.” The response to that idea has been clear and unmistakable: “What took so long?” But then comes the hard part that […]

A Rise in Unreasonable Doubts About Health Science

December 29, 2024 — In recent years, a troubling trend has emerged – a growing distrust in health science, particularly in fields like nutrition and obesity. This skepticism isn’t just about healthy debate or constructive criticism. It’s about an erosion of confidence in scientific expertise. In the age of social media and viral misinformation, unreasonable doubts have real consequences […]

The Enduring Fascination with Causal Pathways for Obesity

August 23, 2024 — A new paper this week reminds us of the enduring fascination with causal pathways for obesity. Why has the prevalence grown so relentlessly? How can we reverse it? This preoccupation has been the source of controversy and mistakes in dealing with obesity. One of the more memorable controversies is the back-and-forth debates between David Ludwig […]

Truth and Light, Carbs and Insulin, Trading Letters in Obesity

May 17, 2024 — “Give a boy a hammer and everything he meets has to be pounded.” Though this hammer-nail-pounding metaphor started half a century ago, it still works well today. For example, folks armed with the carbohydrate insulin model (CIM) of obesity see opportunities everywhere to pound away, bringing truth and light. Whatever the question, carbs and insulin […]